Upload the quote and QuoteScore scores it 0 to 100 against regional pricing benchmarks, line by line, free and with no signup. Across the 325 roofing quotes QuoteScore has scored, 42.5% scored under 50, meaning at least one line was priced above the normal market range for that job and region, so ask for a line-item breakdown before signing. Rule of thumb: 65 or higher is within the normal range, 50 to 64 is worth one competing bid before you sign, and under 50 has specific overpriced lines to negotiate by name.
Before you sign a roofing quote
A roofing quote usually lists tear-off and disposal, the shingle or membrane by product line, underlayment, flashing and drip edge, ridge vent, decking replacement priced per sheet, and labor by the square. QuoteScore reads the quote you already have, as a photo, a PDF or pasted text, splits it into those lines and compares each one against the regional benchmark range for that item, then returns a 0 to 100 fairness score that names the lines priced above market.
Of the 325 roofing quotes scored so far, the average fairness score is 53.7 out of 100 and 42.5% scored under 50, which means at least one line was priced above the normal market range for that work and region. The count updates as new quotes are scored.
The lines that most often push a roofing quote above market are a price per square well above the regional range for the product line, decking replacement charged as a flat sum instead of per sheet, flashing or ventilation added as extras after the fact, and a single total with no squares stated. Before you sign, ask for the number of squares measured, the shingle product and warranty tier, and the per-sheet price for any decking.
The check is free, needs no signup, and the file is deleted the moment the analysis completes. A score under 65 comes with the specific lines to negotiate and the benchmark range each one was measured against, so you can disagree with it.
Common questions about roofing quotes
What does a roofing quote usually include?
Tear-off and disposal, the shingle or membrane by product line, underlayment, flashing and drip edge, ridge vent, decking replacement priced per sheet, and labor by the square. A fair quote itemizes each of those with a quantity and a price; a single lump sum is the first thing QuoteScore flags.
How many roofing quotes has QuoteScore scored?
325 as of October 2026, with an average fairness score of 53.7 out of 100; 42.5% scored under 50. The count updates as new quotes are scored.
What makes a roofing quote score low?
Most often a price per square well above the regional range for the product line, decking replacement charged as a flat sum instead of per sheet, flashing or ventilation added as extras after the fact, and a single total with no squares stated. Ask for the number of squares measured, the shingle product and warranty tier, and the per-sheet price for any decking before you sign.