🚨 All-Time Records

The Hall of Shame:
Most Overpriced Quotes
Ever Analyzed

Real quotes. Real data. All anonymous.
These are the most egregiously overpriced contractor quotes ever submitted to QuoteScore — filtered for quotes over $2,000 with scores below 40/100.

🕐 Last updated: Apr 5, 2026, 12:55 AM UTC

20
Quotes in
the Hall
$329,644
Est. Total
Overpayment
23
Avg Score
(out of 100)
🥇
worst
📋 Other
📍 30319 🔥 ~$75,000 over fair price
"The provided document is an 'Initial Fees Worksheet' for a mortgage loan, not a quote for home services or auto repair. As QuoteScore, I am equipped to analyze…"
See full analysis →
0
$219,294
quoted
🥈
worst
🌡️ HVAC
🔥 ~$29,925 over fair price
"The quote of $63,000 from Bell Brothers for a heat pump replacement, full ductwork upgrade, and attic insulation for a 1700 sq ft home is astronomically high,…"
See full analysis →
5
$63,000
quoted
🥉
worst
🏠 Roofing
📍 Denver, CO 🔥 ~$16,126 over fair price
"The quote from Master Roofing Plus for a shingle roof replacement is significantly overpriced and contains critical discrepancies. The quoted price for…"
See full analysis →
25
$43,003
quoted
#4
rank
📋 Siding
📍 88901 🔥 ~$13,852 over fair price
"This quote for engineered wood siding replacement is significantly higher than average for several key line items, even after adjusting for the 88901 zip code.…"
See full analysis →
35
$42,622
quoted
#5
rank
🏠 Roofing
📍 97201 🔥 ~$17,440 over fair price
"This quote for a shingle roof replacement is extremely high, totaling $41,035. A significant red flag is a major discrepancy in the architectural shingle…"
See full analysis →
15
$41,035
quoted
#6
rank
🪟 Windows
📍 30075 🔥 ~$15,750 over fair price
"This quote for 22 window replacements at $39,375 is significantly above market rates for your area. Even considering high-end fiberglass windows and adjusting…"
See full analysis →
20
$39,375
quoted
#7
rank
🏠 Roofing
📍 83702 🔥 ~$17,431 over fair price
"This quote for a metal roof replacement is significantly overpriced, primarily due to inflated costs for removing the existing roof and the permit fee. While…"
See full analysis →
10
$38,735
quoted
#8
rank
🍳 Kitchen
📍 Savannah, GA 🔥 ~$15,069 over fair price
"This kitchen remodel quote is significantly overpriced with multiple line items far exceeding industry and real-world benchmarks for the 31401 zip code. The…"
See full analysis →
20
$37,672
quoted
#9
rank
🍳 Kitchen
📍 07101 🔥 ~$12,160 over fair price
"This kitchen remodel quote is significantly high, primarily due to inflated prices for countertops and backsplash, which are well above industry benchmarks and…"
See full analysis →
35
$37,415
quoted
#10
rank
📋 Siding
📍 70112 🔥 ~$14,025 over fair price
"This quote for fiber cement siding installation on a 2,400 sq ft 2-story colonial is suspiciously low. Several key line items, including the HardiPlank siding…"
See full analysis →
25
$37,400
quoted
#11
rank
🌡️ HVAC
📍 84101 🔥 ~$13,792 over fair price
"This quote for a heat pump installation is significantly overpriced, with several line items, particularly the equipment, far exceeding industry benchmarks and…"
See full analysis →
15
$32,451
quoted
#12
rank
🏠 Roofing
📍 Kansas City, MO 🔥 ~$10,169 over fair price
"The quote from Patriot Roofing Group for a shingle roof replacement totals $31,289. While some line items are within acceptable ranges, the price for GAF…"
See full analysis →
35
$31,289
quoted
#13
rank
🌡️ HVAC
📍 80202 🔥 ~$12,451 over fair price
"This quote from Eagle HVAC Co. for a heat pump installation is extremely high. Most line items, including the heat pump unit, air handler, refrigerant lines,…"
See full analysis →
20
$31,127
quoted
#14
rank
🌅 Decks
📍 43201 🔥 ~$9,951 over fair price
"This quote for a 200 sqft cedar deck is significantly higher than average for the Midwest region, even with an adjustment for an urban zip code. Several line…"
See full analysis →
35
$30,619
quoted
#15
rank
🌳 Landscaping
📍 New Orleans, LA 🔥 ~$10,785 over fair price
"This quote contains multiple significant red flags, including calculation errors and excessively high pricing for several key items. The quoted price for the…"
See full analysis →
25
$28,761
quoted
#16
rank
🌳 Landscaping
📍 Albuquerque, NM 🔥 ~$10,481 over fair price
"This quote from Trusted Landscaping Plus for a landscape renovation is significantly overpriced and contains multiple red flags regarding pricing transparency.…"
See full analysis →
25
$27,950
quoted
#17
rank
🪟 Windows
🔥 ~$11,050 over fair price
"This quote from Window Nation for 20 'lower quality' window replacements is extremely high, even after significant discounts. The aggressive sales tactics and…"
See full analysis →
15
$26,000
quoted
#18
rank
🌅 Decks
📍 07101 🔥 ~$8,108 over fair price
"This quote for a 250 sqft Trex composite deck is significantly higher than industry benchmarks and real-world data for the Northeast region. Several line…"
See full analysis →
35
$24,949
quoted
#19
rank
🏠 Roofing
📍 Newark, NJ 🔥 ~$8,076 over fair price
"While the overall price for this metal roof replacement is at the low end of the benchmark for a 2200 sq ft home in the Northeast, several critical line items…"
See full analysis →
35
$24,848
quoted
#20
rank
📋 Pool
📍 Austin, TX 🔥 ~$8,003 over fair price
"This quote for pool equipment replacement is significantly higher than average market rates for the Austin, TX area. While some items are within the high end…"
See full analysis →
35
$24,624
quoted
🤔
Is your quote Hall of Shame material?

Upload any contractor quote and find out in under a minute. We'll score every line item against real market data and tell you exactly how much you might be overpaying.

Check My Quote — It's Free →
No signup. No credit card. Takes 30 seconds.