🗓️ Updated Weekly
The Most Overpriced
Contractor Quote This Week
Week of Aug 19 – Aug 25 · Automatically updated every 7 days
🕐 Last updated: Aug 25, 2026, 5:58 AM UTC
10
🚗 Auto Quote
📊 10/100 score
💰 $16,000 quoted
📍 Minturn, CO
🔥 ~$7,200 over fair price
Score of 0–39 = severely overpriced · This quote scored 10/100
📝 AI Summary
This repair scenario is a significant red flag. The initial $8,500 repair failed to resolve the original issue, and the shop is now requesting an additional $7,500 for the same problem, bringing the total to $16,000. This total cost likely far exceeds the market value of a 2009 Porsche Cayenne.
🚩 Flags Found (2)
🚩
Initial Repair Failed to Resolve Problem
The initial $8,500 repair did not fix the original diagnostic codes (P12A2, P2293), and the shop is now requesting an additional $7,500 for the same issue. This indicates a misdiagnosis or an ineffective repair, and you should not be charged twice for the same problem.
🚩
Total Repair Cost Exceeds Vehicle Value
A total repair bill of $16,000 for a 2009 Porsche Cayenne (base model) is highly likely to exceed the vehicle's current market value. This often makes the vehicle a total loss from a financial perspective.
💡 Additional Notes
❓
Lack of Detailed Breakdown for Repairs
The quote provides only summary amounts ($8,500 and $7,500) without itemized parts, labor hours, or specific procedures. This lack of transparency makes it impossible to properly assess the fairness of individual charges.
💡
Seek a Second Opinion
Given the high cost and the failure of the initial repair, it is crucial to get a second opinion from another reputable European or Porsche specialist before authorizing any further work.
📋 Line Items (2)
| Item |
Quoted |
Fair Range |
Assessment |
|
Initial Repair Estimate (failed to fix original issue)
Other
|
$8,500 |
— |
Red Flag |
|
Additional Repairs (P12A2, P2293 related)
Other
|
$7,500 |
— |
Red Flag |
✅
How does your quote stack up?
Upload any contractor quote — roofing, HVAC, auto repair, plumbing, and more. Our AI scores every line item against real pricing data in seconds.
Check My Quote — Free →
Takes under a minute.