HVAC Quote Analysis from Multiple Contractors: 25/100 — Red Flag

Total quoted: $19,320

These quotes for boiler replacement are significantly overpriced, ranging from $19,320 to $26,680. Even the lowest quote of $19,320 for a traditional boiler and indirect tank system is approximately $8,820 above the national average midpoint of $10,500 for such a system, including chimney lining. The high-efficiency combi boiler quote at $26,680 is particularly egregious, being over $13,680 above its fair market value.

Top flag: Boiler Installation Costs Are Highly Inflated

All three quotes present boiler installation costs significantly above national benchmarks. The high-efficiency combi boiler is quoted at $23,680 (excluding chimney lining), which is over $8,000 above the high benchmark. The traditional boiler and indirect tank systems are quoted at $16,320 and $22,000 (excluding chimney lining), both far exceeding the combined high benchmark of $12,500.

View the full line-item breakdown and regional pricing comparison